Democratic senators press CFTC to reverse prediction market order
Photo: Luca Nardone / Pexels
Lawmakers want the agency to halt its push forcing exchanges to drop state-by-state geofencing within 30 days
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission wanted prediction markets to look the same in every state. A group of Democratic senators wants the agency to stop.
The lawmakers have asked the CFTC to halt its prediction market rule and reverse an order it issued on November 5. That order told federally regulated exchanges to tear down their state-by-state digital borders.
What the November 5 order actually does
On November 5, 2026, the CFTC issued interpretive guidance aimed at designated contract markets, or DCMs. These are the exchanges the agency formally oversees for derivatives trading.
The guidance gave those exchanges 30 days to do one of two things. They could remove domestic geographic restrictions, or they could offer a valid justification for keeping them.
Those restrictions are known as geofencing. Think of it as a velvet rope drawn around a map. A platform checks where a user is located and blocks access if that state is off limits.
Exchanges have used geofencing to avoid friction with state regulators. If a state objects to a product, the platform can simply wall that state off. That keeps the peace, at the cost of a patchwork market.
The CFTC’s position is that the patchwork itself is the problem. The guidance argues that such limits cut against the Commodity Exchange Act’s intent for derivatives markets to function uniformly across the country.
CFTC Chairman Michael Selig has framed it in similar terms. He indicated that geographic restrictions are inconsistent with the goals of the Commodity Exchange Act.
The senators push back
Democratic senators see things differently. They are calling on the agency to either pause the guidance or reverse it entirely.
See what prediction markets are pricing into the day's biggest stories.
Daily. Free. Join 34,000+ readers across crypto, finance, and policy.
Several prominent names are involved. Jeff Merkley, Elizabeth Warren, and Adam Schiff are among the Democrats demanding hearings and potential legislation targeting prediction markets.
The timing matters. The pressure follows the 2026 midterm elections, after which Democrats gained control of both the House and the Senate.
Critics of the CFTC’s approach have raised concerns about potential overreach. They have also warned about the risk of unregulated betting spreading into states that had tried to keep these products out.
A turf war that has been building
The November order did not appear out of nowhere. It landed in the middle of an escalating jurisdictional fight between Washington and the states.
The CFTC has been aggressive about asserting its authority. The agency has sued several states for attempting to regulate event contracts.
Event contracts are the core product of prediction markets. A trader buys a position on whether something will or will not happen, and the contract pays out based on the outcome. To a federal regulator, that is a derivative. To some state officials, it looks a lot more like a wager.
Legal confrontations between CFTC-registered platforms and state authorities over event contracts have intensified. Those clashes have, in turn, fueled calls from leading Democrats for closer congressional scrutiny and oversight.
The geofencing guidance is the CFTC’s boldest move in that fight so far. Rather than defending platforms one lawsuit at a time, the agency effectively told exchanges that state-level carve-outs need a justification to survive.
What this means for Kalshi, Polymarket, and the sector
The companies with the most at stake are the prediction market platforms themselves. Kalshi and Polymarket are among those significantly affected by the CFTC’s guidance, as both face conflicts with state regulators.
Their position is awkward. Federal guidance pushes them to open access nationwide. State authorities, in many cases, want the opposite. Complying fully with one side risks a fight with the other.
That squeeze could create real operational headaches. A platform that drops geofencing to satisfy the CFTC may invite new state enforcement. A platform that keeps geofencing needs a justification the agency will accept, and that standard is still being tested.
There are a few things worth watching. The first is whether the CFTC holds firm on its 30-day timeline or softens it under political pressure. The second is whether the senators’ push for hearings turns into scheduled sessions. Hearings would put Selig and the agency’s reasoning under direct public examination. The third, and most consequential, is legislation. Interpretive guidance rests on the agency’s reading of the Commodity Exchange Act. If Congress decides to clarify or rewrite how event contracts are treated, it could settle the federal-versus-state question in a way no lawsuit can.
Disclosure: This article was edited by Estefano Gomez. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.

