Goldman Sachs flags critically low liquidity in S&P futures
Marcus by Goldman Sachs / Wikimedia Commons (Public domain)
Top-of-book depth in S&P 500 E-mini futures has thinned to $1.5 million, leaving prices vulnerable to modest orders
The most traded stock index futures contract on the planet is running on fumes. Goldman Sachs has flagged critically low liquidity in S&P 500 E-mini futures, with top-of-book depth sitting at just $1.5 million.
That matters because modest orders are now moving prices by 0.4% to 0.6%. For a market that typically absorbs enormous flows without blinking, that is a lot of blinking.
What thin liquidity actually looks like
Top-of-book depth measures the dollar value of the best visible bids and offers sitting in the order book at any given moment.
When that number is large, big trades get filled without shoving prices around. When it shrinks, even ordinary trades start chewing through several price levels at once.
The current reading of $1.5 million compares with long-term averages of roughly $13-18 million. Put differently, the cushion that normally sits at the front of the market has shrunk to a fraction of its usual size.
The research behind the warning treats anything below $7 million as a stress signal. By that yardstick, $1.5 million is not flirting with the danger zone so much as living in it.
A pattern, not a one-off
This is not the first dip below the line in recent months. Depth readings came in at $3.8 million in March 2026 and approximately $4.1 million in early 2026.
Both of those figures were already well under the $7 million threshold. The latest print takes the market meaningfully lower still.
The news moving money, markets, and the world—before your day starts.
Daily. Free. Join 34,000+ readers across crypto, finance, and policy.
One of the stranger features of the current environment is that trading volume has frequently stayed high even as order books thinned out. Plenty of people are trading, but fewer are willing to stand in the order book and wait to be hit.
That gap points to market makers stepping back. These are the firms that normally post bids and offers on both sides and profit from the spread between them.
When volatility rises, their risk of getting run over rises too. So they quote smaller sizes, widen their prices, or step away entirely, which leaves the book thinner precisely when traders need it most.
What is driving it
Goldman Sachs analysts track futures depth and price impact closely, and they have tied swings in these conditions to a familiar list of catalysts. Geopolitical tensions, tariff announcements, and earnings reports all feature.
Investor positioning plays a role as well. The firm’s analysis points to Commodity Trading Advisors, or CTAs, and hedge funds as key players whose shifts can amplify moves.
CTAs are systematic funds that tend to follow trends using rules rather than gut feel. When a trend turns, many of them can end up trying to adjust positions in the same direction, which is not ideal when the order book is already thin.
History offers a few reminders of how this can play out. Previous bouts of thin liquidity, including episodes in 2020 and more recent stretches tied to tariffs, have coincided with sharp price swings, and some past instances have been linked to circuit breaker triggers.
What this means for traders and investors
The most immediate cost shows up in execution. When top-of-book depth is this shallow, large orders face more slippage, which is the gap between the price a trader expects and the price they actually get.
The effects may not stay contained to futures. S&P 500 E-mini contracts are widely used for hedging and price discovery, so stress in that market could translate into less predictable moves in the underlying stocks.
Hedging also becomes trickier in this environment. Protection tends to cost more when spreads are wide, and the moments when investors most want to hedge are often the moments when the book is thinnest.
The key gauge to watch is whether depth climbs back toward the $7 million stress line or keeps sliding. Continued readings near $1.5 million would point to a market where modest flows keep producing outsized moves.
Disclosure: This article was edited by Vivian Nguyen. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.

