Skip to content
Advertisement
Propagate co-CEO says Anthropic IPO validates Sam Bankman-Fried’s investing thesis

Propagate co-CEO says Anthropic IPO validates Sam Bankman-Fried’s investing thesis

Photo: Rostislav Uzunov / Pexels

Ben Silverman compared the FTX founder to Icarus as Anthropic's market debut put a spotlight on the stake Alameda Research could not keep

Sam Bankman-Fried once owned a sizable piece of one of the most valuable AI companies on the planet. He is now serving a 25-year sentence after his fraud conviction, and the stake is long gone.

That gap between foresight and outcome was the subject of an interview with Ben Silverman, co-CEO and chairman of Propagate Content, as Anthropic made its trading debut. Silverman, an executive producer on a new documentary series about the fallen FTX founder, argued that the IPO confirmed Bankman-Fried had a strong investing thesis. He also compared his trajectory to Icarus, the figure from Greek myth who flew too close to the sun.

The bet that aged well, for someone else

Alameda Research, the trading firm tied to FTX, put a reported $500 million into Anthropic between 2021 and 2022. That check bought roughly 13.5% to 14% of the company.

Then FTX collapsed in 2022, and Bankman-Fried lost any chance of profiting from the position. FTX and Alameda were forced to part with the Anthropic shares.

The stake was liquidated in 2024, bringing in approximately $1.3 billion for the bankruptcy estate to repay creditors. On paper, that is a healthy return on a $500 million investment made only a few years earlier.

Advertisement

It looks a lot less impressive next to Silverman’s math. He claimed that, had the stake been retained, it could have been worth an estimated $37 to $40 billion based on Anthropic’s IPO valuation.

Anthropic’s debut by the numbers

Anthropic priced its shares at $83 and raised $81.3 billion, making it the largest IPO in history. The company’s shares trade on Nasdaq.

The stock opened at $111.50 before settling back and closing at $97.17. That still left shares up 17% on their first day.

A documentary, a myth and a 25-year sentence

Silverman’s comments came as he discussed Amazon’s new documentary series on Bankman-Fried, titled The Boy Who Stole Billions? The question mark in the title is doing a fair amount of work.

His Icarus comparison captures the tension the series appears built around. Bankman-Fried could spot opportunities early, yet his empire unraveled in spectacular fashion.

The segment also noted that smaller Anthropic stakes held by Bankman-Fried’s associates, Caroline Ellison and Nishad Singh, followed a complicated legal path due to federal seizure efforts.

Bankman-Fried remains behind bars on the 25-year sentence that followed his conviction on fraud charges.

What this means

For FTX creditors, the Anthropic IPO is likely to revive an uncomfortable question. The approximately $1.3 billion from the 2024 sale went toward repayments, but the estimated $37 to $40 billion figure Silverman cited invites a natural comparison with what might have been.

That comparison has limits. A bankruptcy estate exists to return money to creditors, not to hold a concentrated private-company position and hope the market eventually cooperates. Selling in 2024 locked in a known return at a time when Anthropic’s future valuation was anything but guaranteed.

One detail to watch is the ongoing legal treatment of the smaller stakes tied to Ellison and Singh. With Anthropic now publicly traded, any assets caught up in federal seizure efforts carry a clearer market value, which could add new interest to how those proceedings play out.

Disclosure: This article was edited by Vivian Nguyen. For more information on how we create and review content, see our Editorial Policy.